Please reach out to the editor assigned to your paper about this issue. A status of Pending Approval indicates that your application has been reviewed and is ready to be approved, but for administrative reasons, it cannot be approved until the following calendar year. We encourage authors to publish their experimental and theoretical results in as much detail as possible. Here is a short video on manuscript status in Editorial Manager, and some additional articles on the manuscript submission process. Thus, we would be glad for any information concerning this manuscript. The journal staff aim to find expert reviewers within a week, but it can sometimes take longer to find the right match. Please could you get in touch with the Sustainability Editorial Office for further information? Reviewing Your Manuscript Q&A - MDPI Blog Now our paper is accepted, but as I ask from the Section Managing Editor about the author addition. Upon completion of the production steps, the article will be available online. i submitted my revised manuscripts after 2 major revision and one minor revision . The rejection letter from the Editorial Office will contain important information and instructions for you to follow. Since the first day of the submission, we have tried to contact the editorial office along with the Handling Editor, requesting them to assist us in applying the discount vouchers we have obtained from performing peer-review. (hibrain.net) Pending decision means that the Academic Editor is assessing the peer review process. Pending decision = A first assessment will be made by the Academic Editor. They usually have a busy schedule. The APCs currently range from 1000 CHF to 2400 CHF (Swiss Francs). Excuse me, if this status is Pending editor decision, how many days will it take to make a decision? You can speed up the publishing process by responding to requests for action as soon as you can. Im going to chase this up on your behalf. Mdpi . I have an inquiry, I submitted my research article on 27/ 9 / 2022. You can find these templates in the Instructions for Authors section, accessible from the journal menu. The MDPI editorial process. It may take longer than expected if the Academic Editor has a particularly high workload. This stage takes about 1-2 working days, dependent on the editors schedule. MDPI journals do not discriminate against manuscripts with waivers or vouchers. In this article, we will first discuss the overall publishing process, and then describe each manuscript status in detail. Is a long "Ready for Decision" status a bad sign? | Editage Insights Layout editing, as well as a plagiarism check, are offered at a fixed price. If your paper is still being processed (i.e., in one of the many processing stages such as Pending review or Pending editor decision), then you can contact the journals Editorial Office. This is what is meant by 'Pending Decision.' You should know the decision soon. You can find out more about our peer review process, pre-check and other policy requirements here: https://www.mdpi.com/editorial_process. You are therefore encouraged to use the journals Microsoft Word template or LaTeX template (including Overleaf) to prepare your manuscript. MDPI joined CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) early on in the initiatives launch. Apologies for the delay. As youve been waiting for more than a week, you can contact the Assistant Editor for an update. Manuscripts submitted with vouchers and/or discounts are processed in exactly the same way as those without. However, we will allow extra time if you need it. Special Issue deadlines are by date only. I actually think this is unnecessary but the managing section editor request an update of the published paper on the basis of my mail. Hi! Hello, and have a nice day. Is there specific upload guidance or is it attached in revised manuscript as one file? Regarding the significance, our survey is very important for dentists to find out shortages and limitations of Thiet practice and try to correct and improve. Your manuscript has now been published online in PDF format. The status changed to pending editor decision on November 24, 2022 and has remained Pending Editor decision since then. Many apologies for the delay. Do you think how long probably I should keep waiting? The IOAP entitles authors to a 10% discount on APCs. [1] 21 . This stage refers to an internal process. Or should we just wait? Here are the MDPI submission statuses that you might encounter on the SuSy platform. How long does it take in general for an article published in MDPI Microorganisms to show up in PubMed? What should I do to get the editor to take another look at this paper? what does it means? Moreover, We have asked such issues to Assistant Editor and IJERPH Editorial Office multiple times via email. Sorry that this is taking a bit longer than expected. I submitted my paper on Deecmber 19th and after one month of review , the status is showing as pending decions since more than 5 days after one round of review. Please check your emails. on 30.12.22 my manuscript status was accepted , then it changed to pending english. Thank you. It usually takes around 48 hours. The status Revised version review indicates that your paper has been sent for a second round of reviews. can you please tell me the reason why it has been rejected, so that i can correct it and resubmit it. Authors pay a one-time Article Processing Charge (APC) to cover the costs of peer review administration and management, the professional production of articles in PDF and other formats, and the dissemination of published papers in various venues, in addition to free readership and other publishing functions. Yet, our paper has been declined for publication with no resubmission. Hi Prof. Mallikarjuna, thank you for the comment. Language and layout edits, including typography, abbreviations, image quality, and referencing order edits have been made by the Editorial Office for you to review and confirm. Pending decision= Academic Editor (48) Pending major or minor revisions= Pending editor decision Academic Editor Paper accepted= English correction done (24: ) Thank you very much for answering my previous comment. This manuscript status means that your manuscript has officially been accepted for publication. Should we reach out to the assistant editor? Once you are logged in, you can access your manuscript submission. I am worried about the slow process. APCs need to be paid if a paper has been accepted. Please contact the journals Editorial Office immediately, letting them know of your situation. Is there anyway to revised the manuscript? Is it normal to take time. Regarding the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy), what to do if two of the co-authors have the same initials (first and last names)? Time is rather critical for this paper. We are assuming that MDPI is like a money machine nowadays and only or mostly accepted paper without the vouchers code. Hello. APC information is also available via the journal menu. I paid the APC. The status changed from Pending review to Under review on December 15th and the Assistant Editor was also assigned on that day. This stage usually takes around 1-2 working days, but is dependent on the editors workload. They will be able to advise on any waivers and/or discounts available to you. You can resubmit at any time. No changes can be made at any point in the publishing process. It is a perfect fit with an open SI. 2. Thank you. They haven't decided yet. However, if this is related to an error in your formula, then take a look at this detailed policy regarding corrections and retractions. Please could you contact the Agriculture Editorial Office? The status is still Pending Review. I have contacted with the editorial office but I did not get response. To find their details, please go to the journal webpage, and click Editorial Office in the left-hand navigation menu. Ill post again after editing. We forward hearing from you soon. hi, What is your experience as reviewer of MDPI and Applied - ResearchGate Hi, I submitted my manuscript 29, July. My first manuscript rejected. Id like to ask about the status of Pending Editorial Decision which has lasted for more than 10 days. Hi However, I have not yet received a response from the editorial office. You can certainly reach out to the Managing Editor and inform them of this issue. If you know that you wont be able to make a deadline, you should contact the Assistant Editor (Editorial Office) to ask for more time. Decoding your manuscript's status in Editorial Manager - Wolters Kluwer can I ask for payment extension of the apc? That is, unless you have a strong reason why it should not be published, including evidence. You can then submit your full manuscript in November. As an author, you will receive email updates when you need to take action. Our dedicated in-house team completes the administrative work. Please get in touch with the journals Editorial Office. The status of paper is pending decision for 33 days. Thank you very much. Its also important to remember that authors who have their manuscript rejected are refunded the APC. now they asked me for another revision. I submitted paper to agriculture journal number of article is 1972147 and I finished two rounds of major revisions. We also submitted a short text as per instructions given at :https://www.mdpi.com/authors/promoting. Thanks a lot for your time! I encourage you to take a look at the Under review section in this article. Your last chance to make any edits to the paper is the author proofreading stage. What is the procedure? It is first time for me to face this issue in MDPI as I published a lot of papers in MDPI journals and the decision was take after 2days. As such, I am getting worried about the prolonged delay. Plz, reply me. I submitted my manuscript dentistry-2179056 to Dentistry journal 7/1/2023. Please be sure to confirm this with the Assistant Editor as soon as one is assigned to your manuscript. So sorry that you have such conflicting information! Also another point, the process is so long than before do you know why? Hi Islam. Please could you take a look at the Under review section of this article? Dear Madam, So sorry to hear that you are having trouble. If you have made a mistake in your paper, please contact the Editorial Office. Topic: Mdpi | WorkingUS.com MDPI Pending editor decision . It usually takes 1-2 days. Getting Involved with the Editorial Process Q&A, How to Advance as an Early Career Researcher, Challenges and Opportunities: Early Career Researchers, How to Reduce Stress Whilst Waiting for Publication, policy regarding corrections and retractions, Desk rejection (rejection upon submission), Rejection before peer review by the Academic Editor. If the paper was rejected because it did not fall within the scope of the Special Issue, then you can resubmit to a Special Issue that is more fitting. In open peer review, the reviews are published online when the manuscript is. This is unusual of MDPI (data), since the usual time for first review is normally 39 days. In general, if the editor does require more information, they will reach out to you. Our authors publications in English have enabled broad international readership, with more than 14 million MDPI webpage views monthly in 2020. This stage usually takes about 1-5 working days. Traditional journals nowadays take really long time to review, while MDPI can guarantee the speed. Does it have to go through the process of editing again by the MDPI editorial team? However, I understand that you have been waiting for a while now. Hi, Every MPDI manuscript is converted into different formats, ready for publication. Please reach out to the Editorial Office if anything there is unclear. Who can we ask for help beside assigned editor? Please need guidance. After two rounds of revision and the status is pending decision since 31st may 2022. I want to ask what if the different between abstract submission deadline and manuscript submission deadline ? We are getting worried about this long delay. . You can find out about the journals scope in the Aims & Scope section, which can be accessed via the journal menu, or by searching for individual Special Issue webpages. Id encourage you to get in touch with the Editorial Office if its been five working days without an update. pending editor decision mdpi how long - mathtutorweeks.com Because this step is out of MDPIs hands, delays can sometimes be slightly longer. The duration of this status depends on the Academic Editors workload and availability. Is it possible to do edits after the publication extremely necessary one, for example a mistake in formula on which the results are based? We have the opinion that we finished the revision and answered the reviewers comments properly. How long does this process take to complete? or Will there be any weightage with regard to the Review Report sent by Round-1 Reviewers? In fact JCM said the average time for peer review just around 3 weeks! It may be that the journal might be waiting to decide based on the theme of the upcoming issue. However, there is no guarantee that your work will be accepted for publication. You can find their details by visiting the journal webpage and clicking Editorial Office in the left-hand column. This is highly unusual. can you please tell about this? The status is under review. Why check for update logo is not appeared in some paper? But if go through the link the editorial decision is showing rejected and redeclined submission. Hi, We are passionate about publishing high-quality research in all academic and scientific fields. I hope to find the solution from commenting in this blog. If you have questions or queries about the feedback, you can reach out to the Academic Editor assigned to your manuscript, for more details. What shall I do? Or is the academic editor hiring a fourth reviewer? Delays may be a bit longer if the Managing Editor needs to double-check any information. I would like to know the status of our manuscript jcm-2211571 When submitting your manuscript to SuSy, it will start with an option to select whether or not you have used the journals template; some of the fields will already be filled out if you use it. I havent checked my status for two weeks since it was Under Review. You can their find contact information on the journals homepage. What does this mean?. Apologies for the delay. pending editor decision usually takes 1-2 business days , but its showing from last 23.12.22. The Editorial Office will certainly be able to provide further details. They can opt-out of open review for you. The status Resubmitted means that you have now uploaded your revised manuscript. MDPI | The Editorial Process As part of this, the Editorial Office asks reviewers if they want to disclose their identity. One of the Mdpi journals is not accepting authorship change forms (as per the Mdpi website) during the review process. If the SI GE made the shot, sending the paper to another SI led by the same GE in another MDPI journal might be risky for us, and may lead to the same result. I have a concern regarding MDPi policies. What Does My MDPI Manuscript Status Mean? Not necessarily. Hi, good morning! Shams. Assistant Editors also communicate with reviewers and Academic Editors to see if they can recommend a colleague who would make a good reviewer. I already submitted our manuscript and it was under review. I will keep in contact with you via email. Hello, I am the author who submitted the thesis to horticulturae. Our editors are trained to find quality review candidates. Yes, you can use all of your vouchers together, and publish for free! We submitted the manuscript entitled, A Systematic Review of Deep Knowledge Graph-based Recommender Systems, with focus on Explainable Embeddings on 2022-03-22, with manuscript ID: data-1670544. Could you help us contacting the editorial office on our behalf. Could you please help us check if there is anything wrong with our submission? I ask this issue because I am not able to find a way during the submission process. They will advise you of the decision and any action that you need to take. Once the journal has accepted your manuscript for publication, the final steps will be completed. When we are intended to propose authorship changes, after filling authorship changes form, where do we have to upload it? Hi Rob. Dear Ms. Bosworth, Can you please specify that on average how long does a Revised version review take for a paper after major revision? But one reviewer gave -ve report. Alternatively, you could decide to use the credit on your next submission. Hi Amir, you can find information on MDPIs correction and retractions policy here: https://www.mdpi.com/ethics#16, I have submitted my research article on 8th aug. the status is still coming as pending for review. I am getting worried about the delay. Apologies for the wait. I want to know if this decision was made by the SI GE or others. Today I checked as its changed to Pending decision and I see peer reviewers comments. Every manuscript is unique, and some may need additional reviews. I Hope you are well. The reviewing stage is important to journal integrity. It could be because the paper does not fit into the scope of the journal, or because the reviewers felt the findings were incomplete, for example. I would encourage you to contact the Academic Editor for any missed updates. Hope this helps. Hello Katherine Bosworth! could you provide me information that when that status will be updated? Is this how MDPI Journals works? If I submitted an article in mdpi and 3 reviewers review the manuscript. Hello Manish, thanks for getting in touch. Please note that, if there are reviewer recommendations that have not been sufficiently addressed after two rounds of revisions, rejections or resubmissions may be warranted. However, we may ask you to withdraw your paper if a round of revisions will take longer than a month. You can find their details on the journals webpage, by clicking on Editorial Office on the left-hand navigation menu. They can provide you with an update on your manuscript and put your mind at ease. Can you please guide us cz its almost 15 days. one reviewer gave major revision and another reviwer gave minor. We want to change it later if we get aceept result. My manuscript is (Pending a decision). Our article is in the same status from the last 9 days. The status changed from Pending review to Under review on January 5th and the Assistant Editor was also assigned on that day. Is this status necessary after the pending conversion one ? I am sorry to hear that you have been waiting for longer than our estimated time. I submitted a manuscript in animals after the review process one recommends improve the manuscript other recommended rejection, unfortunately, the final editors decision was rejection and decline resubmission. This may take a bit longer if Layout Editors are busier than usual, however we have measures in place to avoid delayseven if any editors on the team are on leave. Around 12 business days. If this happens, you are more than welcome to resubmit your paper at a later date. Regarding your procedure, it takes 1-2 days to display the final decision. For example, how many hours should I add or subtract from GMT? The journals Editorial Office will be able to provide you with an update. However, if your paper has already been published, it will have to remain in open review. Thanks Because today is the 44th day after my first submission date and the status of my article is still unchanged. Thus, we would be glad for any information concerning this manuscript. Please provide the reason for your withdrawal request. MDPIpending editor decision~mdpi_ Now I want to change the submission issue in the same journal, Is this possible to change our submission issue during under review in the same journal? Some may have other commitments, meaning that the reviews are submitted late. Hello Katherine. This may occur if, for example, one or more of the reviewers require(s) more time. Usually, I find that the rejected ones actually needed more work and the ones that were published were good. thanks. MDPI is a different publisher. Status Associate Editor .Review process , 3 . Yes. Then, I resubmitted the manuscript on 1st of October, it went to peer review, two positive responses one with minor revision and second accepted it. Our online submission system, SuSy (https://susy.mdpi.com/), should automatically detect any vouchers associated with your account. Hello Cheng-En. I would like to inquire about the status of my manuscript that has been under review since the 21st of November 2022 [Cells] Manuscript ID: cells-2079368. This usually takes around 1-2 working days, dependent on the editors schedule. 1. Hi Ivana. Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. Im from Palestine (where the world considers it as a low-bank country) and Im a PhD student. 10 Editor Decision 11 Production Services: From Acceptance to Publication 12 Production Steps 14 Scilit: A Powerful Database 16 Contact mdpi.com. One of our core values at MDPI is the speed at which we publish. My article was in pending conversation but now status shows that conversation skipped what does it mean? But not publishing online yet. As to reply back after paper submission by 2-3 days if accepted. Therefore, we received positive comments from three reviewers in the first and the second revision round. few more things I want to confirm.. you have commented You can include additional authors at any time during revisions (before manuscript acceptance). nearly one month ago on the blog. No, you will not pay if your manuscript is rejected. thanks for your question. May I know what the possible reason for the delay is? There may be delays based on the Academic Editors workload and availability upon a decision request. After submitting the revised version and getting back the 3 reviewers comments (Round 2), the current status is now pending decision since 10 days. From sharing the latest MDPI blog news, to showcasing our most popular articles, the newsletters will keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the science world. As this point is not clear in the website https://www.mdpi.com/apc. It is already more than three weeks since my manuscript was submitted, but there is still no feedback from editorial office and the status is still Under review. Hi There is no set percentage with regard to what is acceptable and what is not. I have send email to Metals editorial office and asistance editor who handle my submitted article. Sometimes, delays occur when waiting for feedback from reviewers and Academic Editors. To find out more about specific papers, you can access the feedback on SuSy, and follow up with the journals Editorial Office if you require further details. If you find yourself waiting for more than a week, its best to contact the Assistant Editor for an update. the manuscript has the ID number of jrfm-1985894 now its showing pending editor decision, which much time it will take to give decision? Dear Torres, thank you for your comment. I was wondering if the status is not getting updated due to a technical error. Thank you very much for your comment. It may take longer than expected if the Academic Editor has a particularly high workload. I have submit my paper Id (sustainability-1826830) to sustainability. If you find yourself waiting for more than a week, it's best to contact the Assistant Editor for an update. Unfortunately, as soon as the manuscript is accepted for submission, the authors cannot be changed. If youre still waiting after a week, please could you get in touch with the Editorial Office? After my paper acceptance i am continuously seeing Pending conversion What is the issue behind. Hi Navdeep, thanks for your comment. Hopefully, you will get a decision very soon. Hope this helps! Please dont worry. Hi Ham, you could start by selecting the most appropriate journal from the list at https://www.mdpi.com/ and submitting your academic paper to your chosen journal. Please can you tell me if we want to add aithors during revison for Funding? Author proofreading = Typographic, image quality, references order, callouts or similar layout and language edits have been made, or are being suggested, for authors to review and confirm. Its usually only a paragraph or two. Thanks for the comment, and thank you for being an MDPI author. Please contact the Assistant Editor if you require an extension. I think it is not fear that we has pass the blind review pass and now after acceptance the managing editor decided that they are not accepting our changes regarding author addition. Your manuscript is now being made available as a PDF on the MDPI site. They will consider the latest version of the manuscript, as well as the completed peer review process. Reviewers then have up to two weeks to return their comments, but reviewers may request more time. My status of the manuscript says Conversion Skipped. I have published a few papers in Sustainabiltiy, and had several rejected. Hi, I have a query. I have contacted the Data Editorial Office and I will keep you updated. Please how much similarity is acceptable to MDPI energies? I would like to know the status of our manuscript Cells-2139714. how can I find my submitted paper reviewers emails? The Manuscript ID is horticulturae-2253134. The Academic Editor is currently reviewing the peer review findings. Could you please reach out to the journals Editorial Office? Submitting your manuscript to an MDPI journal involves hours of research, drafting, and formatting, before finally finishing with a paper that youre happy with and ready to publish. . MDPI - MDPI Japan Blog You can upload your revised manuscript by logging in to SuSy, MDPIs manuscript submission system. Can I refund my money that I paid for APC? This is a mandatory step with no additional fee. In addition, MDPI offers Authors Services (https://www.mdpi.com/authors/english) before paper submission. What does it mean? The first round of reviews usually takes around two to three weeks. You can then apply the feedback to your manuscript and submit the corrections. Last decision: Reject Reviewer 3 Ole Jonny Klakegg Major (Report sent on 13 October 2020) Last decision: Reconsider after major revision. Of course, authors can track the status of their paper. In rare cases, reviewers do need a bit more time to assess the manuscript and make changes. Since the date of submission, the manuscript is still under the Review status. Your paper will be published in under 24 hours. This comes after the paper is accepted. Our Editorial Office may agree to extended revision time, provided that the authors send their request to the in-house Assistant Editor. While submitting the paper, I pasted an abstract directly from my latex editor that contains dollar signs $ before a number. An abstract is a short summary of your research. One more thing I want to confirm. Information on service function by APC breakdown is provided, as well as accepted currency and methods of payment. Id recommend waiting until Tuesday next week. Please feel free to reach out to the Assistant Editor for an update. Many reviewers of traditional journals agree to review but do not deliver ON TIME. The manuscript was submitted on January 17, 2023. I was asked to review for an MDPI journal and realized while requesting to extend the deadline for my review that the editor at MDPI intended to send review requests to several reviewers, to gather enough reviews to make a decision on the basis of the first 2-3 he received. Yes, you can change to a different Special Issue, even while your paper is still being processed. Hello Katherine, Thank you very much! As you have been waiting for over a week, we will investigate and prioritise this issue. Thank you for getting in touch. is pending. They can give you the details. We could not find specific box to upload it in susy. This depends on the nature of the update. I am getting worried about the delay. We have been waiting for over five days. Good morning! So, based on your two rounds of revisions, the Associate Editor (AE) has made their decision on the manuscript and communicated it to the EIC, who will make the final decision.