And is the fact that it is unknowable perhaps related to the fact that time seems to be unavoidably directional, meaning there is no way to go back to gather evidence once lost. But what happens, when we find out exactly how brains work? For these reasons, the knowledge and the knower, both may remain unknown. What role do experts play in influencing our consumption or acquisition of knowledge? TOK Exhibition- Are some things unknowable. Smiling Assassin Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later. Given that the Exhibition is to be based on either an optional theme or the core theme, the question of the methodology of the field does not apply, since there is no field to which Knowledge and Language or Knowledge and Indigenous Societies, or Knowledge and the Knower applies, at least in the context of the TOK course. The knowledge about the future is uncertain, requires justification, could be bias, has limitations and many other things. My pedagogical instinct would be to go with the first of these two strategies so as to make the IA task as natural an extension to daily TOK teaching and learning as possible. Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website. ; The objects may be digital rather than physical objects. This way with sufficient information, predicting the future would be possible, but all experiments suggest that the universe isnt deterministic. One more than 4 = 5. He told me that if the author was religious, he/she would insist that act was purely miraculous and that any other reason other than God expressing images through her is wrong. Throughout human history we considered much knowledge to be unknowable. Unknowable Thing: Whats in a set of sets that dont contain themselves? Does some knowledge belong only to particular communities of knowers? This photo created outrage because his smile makes document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Design a site like this with WordPress.com. What will the cost of living be next year. I think you need stronger consideration of what does or does not make something unknowable. Follow the link below to take you to knowledge & religion. Are something unknowable Tok? Fossils - real world context: -Evidence about the past -Of how dinosaurs lived -Their existence etc -Scientists think dinosaurs are the ancestors of modern lizards and birds -Use scientific evidence to speculate the biology of dinosaurs, Linking context to prompt: -Prompts thinking: would we ever know how real pterodactyls looked, sounded, and/or behaved? be unknowable because of the personal knowledge that I have about my own emotions. Electrons are now thought of as probability functions rather than particles; we can calculate where they are likely to be, but not where they are they could actually be anywhere. Change). As is made clear on p.40 of the Guide, Students must select one of the following IA prompts on which to base their exhibition, and all three objects must be linked to the same prompt.. Well talk a little more about the commentaryhere, but just keep that in mind as you choose your objects. But now Im starting to think the perspectives thing might make my point kind of unclear and was wondering if I should remove or shorten it to make it even more concise because the word limit is quite limiting. Are Some Things Unknowable Tok? The examples given in both cover a wide range of types of objects, and the sample Exhibition files in the Teacher Support Material likewise all feature different types of objects. It is, therefore, important that students identify specific objects to discuss rather than using generic objects and generic images (p.42). Reply Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Technically, the principle says that you cant know the position and momentum of a particle simultaneously. Or am I misunderstanding his face because he shows my way of demonstrating This is another mind bender proved by Alan Turing. Follow the link below to take you to knowledge & politics. The concept dates back to 1900 when David Gilbert proposed 23 "problems" in mathematics that he would like to see solved in the upcoming century. This is part two of a follow-up Q&A post where David Spooner, the host of our webinars, has answered all of your questions. One of the samples in the Teacher Support Material features a song, Strange Fruit by Billie Holliday, and the student has included in their Exhibition a photograph of the cover of the 7 single release of the song. This gave rise to the theory that the universe is deterministic so no point in life, since we're also made of particles. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. They may be objects that the student has created themselves, but they must be pre-existing objects rather than objects created specifically for the purposes of the exhibition The specific real-world context of each object is extremely important to the task. In practice, the objects (and IA prompts) should have something to do with the themes you have studied in TOK: either the core theme (knowledge and the knower), or one of the optional themes ( Knowledge and language, religion, technology, indigenous societies or politics ). For example, no-one knows when Shakespeare was born (although we do know when he was baptized). Identification This is an image of an girl named Akiane Kramarik posing next to a painting she did The painting is called Prince of Peace'', and she was only eight years old when she painted it. Does S contain itself? 19. This reasoning however is flawed, as it is possible to invent countless antigods, for whom the consequences are exactly opposite, cancelling out the infinities. To what extent is objectivity possible in the production or acquisition of knowledge? As a chemistry facilitator, may I use the periodic table or any apparatus or equipment e.g. Thats why I used the cover of the book Beat the Dealer as an example of the knowledge wrongly considered as unknowable but later proved to be able to comprehend and use in our life. A generic Buddha image downloaded from the Internet only for the purpose of the IA task clearly lacks these contexts, whereas the two instances mentioned above do meet these criteria. Either of these could stimulate the kind of discussion suggested here. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. A concept like Godel's Incompleteness Theorem or digits of pi is a go-to but it really depends on your ToK teacher if he/she counts this as an object for exhibition. The philosophical problem is about the lack of knowledge when it comes to rare events that never happened before. Mathematics, however, it equally poses challenges about the knowledge we possess about prime numbers. While the third object can be objectively proven to be something unknowable, its important to notice that in case of both objects one and two and the introduction we have to assume that some popular belief is shared by everyone, while its provably not true there were economists that predicted the 2008 financial crisis just as there where attempts in the ancient times of creating a way of viewing the world not based on myth. The Guide clarifies that a discussion and photograph of a students baby brother is an example of an object that has a specific real-world context, whereas a generic image of a baby from an Internet image search is not (p.42). Is a piece of music an object? What constraints are there on the pursuit of knowledge? Is it, however, possible for some things to be unknowable? This is a problem in the philosophy of mathematics. He proved that its impossible to automatically determine which will happen I know you might argue you could run the program and see what happens but supposing it only stops after 7 trillion years? According to some theories, there exist levels of consciousness3 that we are able to measure. World War II started in 1939 but Turing had been working on code-breaking at Bletchley Park for a year before that; trying to decipher the German Enigma code. The image above represents pi and infinity which are both mathematical symbols. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. This is why I mentioned that perhaps the safety first approach of insisting upon the use of physical objects might be best for the first cohort of students, until we have seen comments from moderators and the publication of the first Subject Report, which may offer further clarification regarding what does, and does not, count as an object. In short, the TOK exhibition is a. Our limits of comprehension may result from insufficient technology or lack of prior knowledge in this matter. The short answer is that, provided the model was not made specifically for the TOK Exhibition, and there is a clearly communicable context for it (made as part of my Visual Arts class, made when I was in primary school, made as an entry for a model-making competition in Grade 10 or whatever), there should be no problem with this. While the TOK essay connects the prescribed title to the relevant AOKs, the TOK exhibition explores how TOK manifests in the real world through the specific real-life objects of personal importance with an IA prompt within one of the TOK themes. IB ToK Exhibition: The Definitive Guide (2021) - Nail IB It suggests ways of presenting ideas to an audience. It was clear that a manual approach was too slow and Turing specified the first decoding machine (called a Bombe), this led to Colossus arguably the first programmable, digital computer that could automatically run through many possible keys. His work was so important to decryption that much remained secret long after the war ended; some was only published this year 60 years after it was written. / Is a vaccination an object? On the other hand, asking students to first choose a prompt and then proceed to look at the world around them with a view to choosing objects which unpack the knowledge issues in the prompt can also yield valid insights. Philosophical treasures from the library of the university of oxford (some intriguing objects). Here, the IA prompt presents the opportunity to choose an object that is unknown to a student. Arguably, if the student chooses to focus their IA on the optional theme Knowledge and Technology, it is more likely that the object possesses communal rather than personal significance (although My First Ever Computer might encompass both), whereas if the focus is on the core theme, Knowledge and the Knower, it may be that the object possesses only personal significance. happiness? If the personal examples is a requirement, I don't think any of your examples could be used. . The same prompts remain available for the duration of this specification (this means that they don't change every year, as opposed to the essay titles). Note that the subreddit is not run by the International Baccalaureate. * Beat the Dealer: A Winning Strategy for the Game of Twenty-One *Full PDF | by Fzwz | Feb, 2021 | Medium src=https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/c7Mws_HMxtpdNUQ_ayHh3eiSaBaWO42tJktc4Bw517ci-zF7PnewPK9ripgkcMg_qrlQue-XerOEqQxZ9y6Rs3b0P_ZAkJ3efXKZdTqSchfujUT8TopWEDxdE2e77chWk6oFEdw” width=305 height=410>. What Is Unknowable? - Intellectual Roundtable TOK First Draft - TOK - Question : Are Some Things Unknowable? Object 1 It is impossible to determine the state of the animal, unless the box is opened and the cat directly observed. Follow the link below to take you to knowledge & language. The concept dates back to 1900 when David Gilbert proposed 23 problems in mathematics that he would like to see solved in the upcoming century. Activate your 30 day free trialto unlock unlimited reading. Unknowable Thing: In mathematics, there are true things that can't be proved true - and we don't know what they are. DUDE BOTH OF THOSE OBJECTS ARE EXACTLY WHAT I CHOSE IM SO SMART. The question if there are unknowable things with our current technology is easy to answer yes, there are, but as it is impossible to predict the future, it is impossible to say whether these things will remain such. To paraphrase Carl Sagan, extraordinary courses require extraordinary resources. As for how its related to the prompt, I plan on exploring a greater force out there and is this force unknowable and not whether she painted it. Darwin theorized that facial expressions evolved to contribute to civilization. Object 1: So, conceivably, a corporate logo could be used to illuminate knowledge issues raised in this specific context but, as with every object chosen, this contextualisation would have to be very precise. The only way we can know that this kind of god exists, is by stating that we believe this fact to be true, which will be a purely personal experience. In addition to this, he is an IB Verification Visitor and Consultant for schools wishing to adopt the IB Diploma. This can make things unknowable. If yes, would the context matter or its projection/interpretation? Students must retain their focus on the nature of the knowledge, in this case, and how the knower plays an important part in exploring and finding ways to go beyond the current set of truth available. So, if you meet anyone you think is uninteresting, you must have got it wrong. His argument is based on the infinite consequences of God existing either eternal damnation if one does not believe, or heaven if one does. Unknowable Thing: Where is that particle, and how fast is it going? It makes sense, becomes an object, in the context of a particular discussion, or debate, and it would be expected that the student contextualises it thus. Find out more HERE. I have difficulties coming up with Now customize the name of a clipboard to store your clips. Miracle (religious) -Since Akiane herself said that she saw visions of Jesus Christ, followers of the Christianity religion (Christians) consider her feat a miracle, Training, genius (artist) -As mentioned before, eight year olds normally dont have the ability to do this -Others might consider Akiane an artistic prodigy, but might be more hesitant on the religious claims -Or wonder about what kind of special training she received -Or perhaps its absolute pure, sheer talent, Fraud (skeptics) -Some might even question whether Akiane was the one who really painted it -Nobody really has evidence to validly discredit her feat though. You need to choose three objects for your exhibition, that should relate closely to the IA prompt that you have chosen, and enable you to create a 950-word commentary set within the context of anoptionalorcoretheme. The movie consists of Elliot, his friends, and family helping E.T. My prompt: Are some things unknowable?DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE TOK PACKET (THIS NEW ADDRESS WORKS)http://www.getanaintok.com/freestuffTOK Essay Tutoringhttps://www.fiverr.com/share/NEAQ6VTOK Exhibition Tutoring:https://www.fiverr.com/share/V7AB8BGet a great score in the International Baccalaureate Diploma Programme by scoring as high as you can in Theory of Knowledge! Heisenbergs reasoning goes like this: How do I find out where a particle is? Read more in our Cookie Policy. Jamie founded Listverse due to an insatiable desire to share fascinating, obscure, and bizarre facts. Smiling Assassin 1. According to his theory, which is now agreed to be a part of modern physics, the cat is in a superposition of being dead and alive at the same time. Are some things unknowable? - WordPress.com The Eye of Providence is a very interesting object to choose. Except, The smallest positive integer not definable in under eleven words only contains ten words, so you can define it in under eleven words. Instant access to millions of ebooks, audiobooks, magazines, podcasts and more. I Does knowing a bit counts as unknowable or even if we know a great amount of information about something but not fully, still counts as unknowable. Mathematicians used to think that there is no strategy to win in blackjack, assuming that its just a card game, based on randomness. But this metaphor extends to events outside the financial market. In fact, you can split sets into two types those that contain themselves and those that dont. Should some knowledge not be sought on ethical grounds? There was an interview with Akiane, and her explanation of how she painted it was that she saw the face of Jesus Christ in her visions. Is it because of incompleteness of the information? Share this: Twitter Could acceptable objects include a tattoo or a vaccination? The following are illustrative examples. My friend who is a Virgo did not see any of the future forecast true as per astrology predictions, yet she genuinely and regularly looks for horoscope speculations every week. Use the links below to take you to the core and optional themes. A set is a collection of objects for example, you could have the set of positive even numbers that contains 2, 4, 6, 8 or the set of prime numbers containing 2, 3, 5, 7, 11 so far so good. There are much bigger numbers out there though; a googolplex is 1 followed by a googol zeroes and the mathematician Stanley Skewes has defined numbers much bigger than a googolplex. An object = a product of knowledge that is accessible for all but is not generic/symbolic. For the record, I believe the different perspectives above are valid possibilities and am open minded to believe any explanation with sufficient evidence. and so on. All three objects must be linked to the same prompt students are encouraged to root their exhibition in one of the TOK themeseither the core theme or one of the optional themes. 35 IA prompts - TOK His children survived the war and they were reunited in 1946, although most of his extended family were killed by the German occupiers. What is the relationship between knowledge and culture? How is current knowledge shaped by its historical development? Levels of Consciousness and Self-Awareness: A Comparison and Integration of Various Views. People are always trying to find a <meaning= and <significance= in the world to satisfy themselves for the future and life after death. The three TOK exhibition objects which I have chosen are: The complete details of TOK exhibition object 1 can be taken from here. Theory of knowledge (TOK), a unique study of epistemology in the IB Diploma Programme, opens up a wide window of reflection on the nature of the knowledge you have constructed as a knower and the process of knowing. What is the relationship between personal experience and knowledge? However, Im quite worried that they arent personal enough as I havent actually seen any of them in real life. If it does, then it shouldnt be in the set, but if it doesnt, then it should. Does all knowledge impose ethical obligations on those who know it? With our current technology, another beings consciousness is definitely unknowable, but with the scientific progression, in the future we may define this term differently, so it could be unknowable with that technology. You get to critically reflect on the reliability of information treated as knowledge through the twelve TOK concepts. This subreddit encourages questions, constructive feedback, and the sharing of knowledge and resources among IB students, alumni, and teachers. see this often when parents of screaming children smile in the mall. Do not sell or share my personal information. Anyways here are my objects and a general outline as to where I plan on going with them: Prompt: Are some things unknowable? What is the relationship between knowledge andculture? What counts as good evidence for a claim? He reasoned that a computer program must either run forever or stop. How might the context in which knowledge is presented influence whether it is accepted or rejected? To me, a poem is an object; if a tweet is an object, then is this also true of a poem? However, they must be specific objects that have a specific real-world contextobjects that exist in a particular time and place (including virtual spaces). 28 is the next perfect number. and faster than light travel is literally impossible, then it is arguable unknowable, as we are literally unable to travel those distances to interact with aliens, and they are likewise constrained in visiting us. Chaitins constant is an example of what seems normal and sensible to a mathematician, but crazy sounding to the rest of us. The Teacher Support Material offers the following advice: Students are encouraged to select objects that have personal relevance or that link to areas of personal interest. The assessment instrument for the Exhibition places great emphasis on the specific real-world contexts (Guide p.47) of the objects chosen. TOK Exhibition - are these objects ok : r/IBO - reddit The problem is that although youre happy to write an infinite number of programs, that infinity is way smaller than the infinite number of real numbers, so there must be many (in fact, most) real numbers missing that cant be calculated.